CARM अनुपालन

CBSA's Updated Trade Verification Priorities: What the New Focus on Steel, Aluminum, and Trade Agreement Compliance Means for Your Import Program

CustomsLogIQ 11 मिनट पढ़ें

CBSA's updated Trade Compliance Verification priorities put steel, aluminum, and CUSMA origin claims squarely in the crosshairs. If you've been claiming preferential tariff treatment without airtight documentation, an auditor may find the problem before you do. This post walks through what CBSA is checking, what's at stake, and how to review your own exposure before a verification letter arrives.

CBSA just updated its Trade Compliance Verification priorities, and if you're importing steel, aluminum, or anything covered by a retaliatory tariff, your file is a lot more likely to land on an auditor's desk than it was a year ago. McMillan LLP flagged this in two separate client alerts, and the message is pretty clear: CBSA is specifically targeting trade agreement compliance claims, including CUSMA origin declarations, and goods where importers claimed relief from Canada's retaliatory tariffs.

This isn't a vague "we're watching everything" announcement. These are named commodity groups, named tariff treatments, and a named compliance gap CBSA wants to close. If you've been claiming CUSMA preferential rates on steel or aluminum without airtight origin documentation, now is the time to find out, before an auditor does it for you.

And with CBSA's November 2026 update to its Assessment and Revenue Management system adding more visibility into importer account history, the agency has better tools than ever to flag patterns across your entries. That matters for how you think about your exposure right now.

What CBSA Actually Said

CBSA publishes its Trade Compliance Verification priorities to signal where it plans to focus audit resources. Think of it as the agency telling you, in writing, where it thinks importers are getting things wrong. The updated list expands scrutiny in three areas that matter most for this discussion:

  • Steel and aluminum imports, particularly goods in HS Chapters 72, 73, 76, and related headings
  • Goods subject to Canada's retaliatory tariffs, where importers claimed an exclusion or exemption
  • Trade agreement compliance claims, with CUSMA/USMCA origin declarations called out specifically

McMillan's reporting on this is worth reading directly. Their alert on the retaliatory tariff angle notes that CBSA is looking hard at whether importers who claimed relief actually qualified for it under the narrow criteria CBSA has set out. McCarthy Tétrault made the same point in their guidance piece, noting that CBSA has been working to narrow the scope of that relief, not expand it.

The practical translation: if you claimed a tariff exclusion and your documentation is thin, you're exposed.

Why Steel and Aluminum Are Always on the List

These commodities have been a compliance headache for years, and not just in Canada. The combination of anti-dumping duties, countervailing duties, retaliatory tariffs, and trade agreement rules of origin creates a situation where the difference between the right tariff treatment and the wrong one can be enormous.

A steel service centre we worked with a few years back was importing hot-rolled coil from a U.S. distributor and claiming CUSMA preferential treatment. Seemed straightforward. The coil was shipped from the U.S., the supplier was American. Problem was, the U.S. distributor had sourced the coil from a third country and hadn't substantially transformed it. The origin claim didn't hold up. The importer owed duties going back three years, plus interest, plus a penalty under the Administrative Monetary Penalty System. The total hit was over $180,000.

That's not a horror story designed to scare you. That's a Tuesday in trade compliance.

For steel and aluminum specifically, HS heading 7208 and the surrounding headings in Chapter 72 are where a lot of the risk lives. Flat-rolled products, bars, rods, wire, tubes, pipes, and structural shapes all have their own classification nuances, and the origin rules under CUSMA for these products are some of the most demanding in the agreement.

CUSMA Origin Claims: What CBSA Is Actually Checking

CUSMA preferential treatment isn't automatic just because your goods came from the U.S. or Mexico. You need to be able to prove origin, and the standard for steel and aluminum is high.

CBSA's verification of CUSMA claims typically looks at three things:

  1. The certification of origin. Did you get one? Is it complete? Does it cover the goods on the specific commercial invoice? A blanket certification that doesn't match the shipment details is a problem.
  2. The underlying evidence. Can your supplier actually back up the origin claim? A certification is only as good as the records behind it. CBSA can ask you to get that information from your supplier, and if the supplier can't produce it, your claim falls apart.
  3. The tariff classification on the certification. If the HS code on the certification doesn't match what you declared on your CAD, that's a flag. Auditors notice that.

Under CUSMA, the rules of origin for steel are particularly strict. The "melt and pour" requirement means that for many steel products, the steel must be melted and poured in North America to qualify. If your U.S. supplier is re-rolling or processing steel that originated outside North America, the goods likely don't qualify, regardless of where the processing happened.

Pull up your last 10 certifications of origin for steel or aluminum shipments. Check whether they reference the correct HS heading, whether they're signed by someone with actual knowledge of the origin, and whether you have any documentation from your supplier to back up the claim. If the answer to any of those is "I'm not sure," that's your starting point.

For more on how CBSA evaluates these claims, the D11-4-2 memorandum on CUSMA origin verification is the document you want to read. It's not exciting, but it tells you exactly what an auditor is going to look for.

Retaliatory Tariffs and the Exclusion Problem

Canada's retaliatory tariffs, introduced in response to U.S. trade actions, added a whole new layer of complexity. Some importers applied for exclusions. Some claimed relief based on guidance that was, frankly, not always clear. And now CBSA is going back through those claims.

McCarthy Tétrault's guidance piece makes an important point here: CBSA has been working to narrow, not broaden, the interpretation of who qualifies for relief. If you read an early bulletin, thought you qualified, and filed accordingly, you may be looking at a different answer now.

The goods most at risk are ones where importers made a judgment call on eligibility without getting a formal ruling or legal opinion. That's understandable. The timelines were tight, the guidance was evolving, and nobody wanted to pay an extra 25 percent tariff if they didn't have to. But "I thought we qualified" is not a defence that holds up well in a CBSA verification.

If you claimed a retaliatory tariff exclusion on any shipment in the past three years, you need to have the documentation that supported that claim ready to produce. That means the exclusion order itself, the evidence that your goods fell within its scope, and any correspondence or legal advice you relied on. If you can't locate that file right now, that's a problem worth solving today.

How a CBSA Trade Verification Actually Works

A lot of importers have never been through a formal verification. Here's how it typically goes, so you're not surprised.

CBSA sends a letter. It identifies a commodity or tariff treatment they want to review, asks for documentation supporting your declarations, and gives you a deadline, usually 30 days. The letter will reference specific CAD numbers or a date range.

You gather your records: commercial invoices, bills of lading, certifications of origin, supplier declarations, any rulings or legal opinions you relied on. You submit them. CBSA reviews and either accepts your documentation or comes back with questions.

If CBSA determines you owe duties, they issue a re-determination under section 59 of the Customs Act. You have 90 days to appeal to the CBSA President, and if that doesn't go your way, you can go to the Canadian International Trade Tribunal.

The process sounds manageable. And it is, if your records are in order. If they're not, 30 days is not enough time to reconstruct three years of supplier documentation from scratch. That's why you do this work now.

Your Self-Audit Checklist

Don't wait for the letter. Here's a practical sequence for reviewing your own exposure before CBSA does it for you.

Step 1: Identify Your Risk Shipments

Pull a report from your customs broker or your CARM portal showing all entries for the past three years where you claimed CUSMA preferential treatment, or where the goods fall in HS Chapters 72, 73, or 76. Also pull any entries where you claimed a retaliatory tariff exclusion or a special tariff treatment code related to the trade actions.

That's your universe of risk. It might be 20 entries. It might be 2,000. Either way, you need to know what you're dealing with.

Step 2: Check Your Certifications of Origin

For every CUSMA claim, you need a valid certification of origin. Under CUSMA, the certification doesn't have to be on a specific form, but it does need to include all the required data elements. Go through your file and confirm:

  • You have a certification for each shipment, or a blanket certification that legitimately covers the period
  • The HS code on the certification matches what you declared
  • The certification is signed by someone at the exporter or producer with actual knowledge
  • The certification isn't expired (blanket certifications are typically valid for up to 12 months)

Missing certifications are fixable, sometimes. You can go back to your supplier and get a retroactive certification, as long as the underlying facts support the origin claim. But you need to do that before CBSA asks, not after.

Step 3: Pressure-Test the Origin Claim

A certification is not proof of origin. It's a declaration. CBSA knows this, which is why they verify.

For steel and aluminum, ask your supplier directly: where was this material melted and poured? If they can't answer that question, or if the answer is "somewhere in Asia," your CUSMA claim is at risk. Get that answer in writing, and get the supporting documentation, mill certificates, production records, whatever your supplier can provide.

This conversation is uncomfortable sometimes. Suppliers don't always love being asked to justify their certifications. But an uncomfortable conversation with a supplier is a lot better than a $180,000 reassessment.

Step 4: Review Your Retaliatory Tariff Claims

For any entry where you claimed an exclusion from retaliatory tariffs, locate the exclusion order you relied on and confirm your goods actually fell within its scope. The exclusion orders are specific. They reference HS codes, end uses, and sometimes specific product descriptions. If your goods were close but not quite within the exclusion, that's a problem.

If you have any doubt, consider filing a voluntary amendment before CBSA contacts you. Self-corrections generally result in lower penalties than corrections made after a verification begins.

Step 5: Check Your CARM Records

CBSA's November 2026 CARM update is worth paying attention to here. The system now gives CBSA cleaner visibility into your account history, including how entries have been amended over time and whether there are patterns across your filings. Your compliance history is more visible now than it was even a year ago.

If you have outstanding corrections or amendments that haven't been filed, they're sitting there in your account. Get them cleaned up. And if you haven't fully worked through your CARM readiness checklist, make sure your account is set up correctly, your financial security is in place, and your broker delegation is properly configured. An auditor looking at your account should see a clean, organized importer, not a pile of unresolved transactions.

What Happens If CBSA Finds Something

If a verification turns up a problem, you're looking at a few possible outcomes.

Duties and taxes owed, plus interest. The interest rate on customs debt is not trivial. It compounds. On a large reassessment, the interest alone can be significant.

AMPS penalties. The Administrative Monetary Penalty System has specific penalties for incorrect tariff treatment claims and false origin declarations. These are tiered based on your compliance history. A first offence for an incorrect tariff treatment might be $1,000 to $5,000 per occurrence. Repeat offences go up from there. If CBSA determines the misrepresentation was intentional, the penalties are much higher and you're potentially looking at prosecution under the Customs Act.

Increased scrutiny going forward. Once you're flagged, you tend to stay flagged for a while. CBSA can require you to provide additional documentation at the time of import, which slows things down and adds cost.

The self-correction route, filing amendments before CBSA contacts you, generally results in reduced penalties. It's not a free pass, but it's meaningfully better than being caught.

Getting an Advance Ruling Before Your Next Shipment

If you're genuinely uncertain whether your goods qualify for CUSMA treatment or whether a retaliatory tariff exclusion applies, you can ask CBSA for an advance ruling. This is a binding decision on origin or tariff classification that gives you certainty before you import.

The process takes time, typically 120 days, so it's not a solution for shipments already in transit. But for an ongoing product line where you've been making a judgment call on origin, getting a ruling is the right move. It protects you, and it gives you something concrete to show an auditor if they ever come knocking.

You can learn more about how the advance ruling process works and what documentation CBSA requires to make a determination.

A Word on Your Customs Broker

Your broker files your entries based on the information you give them. If you tell your broker the goods qualify for CUSMA and provide a certification of origin, your broker will claim CUSMA. If the underlying origin claim is wrong, that's your problem, not your broker's. The importer of record is responsible for the accuracy of the declaration.

That's not a criticism of brokers. It's just how the Customs Act works. Your broker can flag risks and ask questions, and a good broker will. But they can't verify your supplier's production records. You have to do that part.

Talk to your broker now about which of your commodity lines are in the high-risk categories. Ask them to pull your compliance history and flag anything that looks questionable. That conversation is a lot easier to have proactively than after a verification letter arrives.

Frequently Asked Questions

How far back can CBSA go in a trade verification?

Generally four years from the date of accounting, which is the date your entry was filed. In cases of fraud or misrepresentation, there's no limitation period. For most importers dealing with honest errors, four years is the practical window. That means entries filed as far back as late 2022 are potentially in scope right now.

My supplier gave me a certification of origin. Isn't that enough?

It's a start, but it's not the finish line. CBSA can ask you to verify the certification, which means going back to your supplier for the underlying records. If your supplier can't produce those records, or if the records show the goods don't actually qualify, the certification doesn't protect you. You're the importer of record. The obligation to ensure the claim is accurate sits with you.

What's the difference between a trade verification and an audit?

In practice, not much. CBSA uses the term "trade compliance verification" for the process of reviewing specific entries or tariff treatments. A broader review of your overall compliance program might be called an audit. Both involve producing records, both can result in reassessments and penalties, and both are best handled with organized documentation and, in most cases, legal counsel.

Can I fix a wrong tariff treatment claim after the fact?

Yes, through a voluntary amendment or a request for a re-determination. If you catch an error before CBSA contacts you, file the correction. You'll owe the duties and interest, and you may still face a reduced AMPS penalty, but you'll be in a much better position than if CBSA finds it first. The process for self-corrections has specific timelines and procedures, so talk to your broker or trade counsel about the right approach for your situation.

We import steel from a U.S. service centre. How do we know if it qualifies for CUSMA?

You need to ask your U.S. supplier where the steel was originally melted and poured. For most steel products under CUSMA, the melt and pour must have occurred in Canada, the U.S., or Mexico. If your service centre bought coil or bar from a non-North American mill and processed it in the U.S., the resulting product likely doesn't qualify for CUSMA preferential treatment, regardless of how much work was done in the U.S. Get the mill certificates and trace the origin back to the source.

What should I do if I get a CBSA verification letter?

Don't ignore it and don't panic. Read it carefully, note the deadline, and immediately contact your customs broker and, depending on the size of the potential exposure, a trade lawyer. Gather the records referenced in the letter. If you need more time to compile documentation, you can request an extension, CBSA will usually grant a reasonable extension if you ask before the deadline, not after. Respond completely and accurately. Partial responses or vague answers tend to extend the process and increase scrutiny.

स्वचालन के लिए तैयार हैं?

मुफ़्त क्रेडिट से सीमा शुल्क का काम आसान बनाएँ

वर्गीकरण, मूल्यांकन और अनुपालन अनुसंधान में समय बचाएँ, ऐसे टूल के साथ जो आपके वर्कफ़्लो को सरल बनाते हैं और हर निर्णय में सहायता करते हैं।