Tuân thủ CARM

CBSA's Updated Trade Verification Priorities: What the New Steel, Aluminum, and Trade Agreement Focus Means for Your Import Program

CustomsLogIQ 11 phút đọc

CBSA's November 2026 update to its trade compliance verification priorities puts steel, aluminum, and preferential tariff claims under closer scrutiny than they've been in years. If you're importing under HS chapters 72, 73, or 76, or claiming CUSMA preference on any goods, the risk of receiving a verification notice is real. This post walks through what CBSA is looking for, how the retaliatory surtax rules complicate things, and what a practical self-audit looks like before an officer comes knocking.

CBSA quietly updated its Trade Compliance Verification priorities in November 2026, and if you're importing steel, aluminum, or goods claiming preferential tariff treatment under CUSMA or any other trade agreement, your file just moved closer to the top of their list. McMillan LLP flagged this in two separate pieces this month, and the signal is clear: CBSA is deliberately targeting commodity categories that are already tangled up in Canada's retaliatory tariff environment.

This isn't a routine housekeeping update. It's an enforcement shift. And if your import program hasn't been stress-tested against the current surtax rules and origin documentation requirements, a verification notice is going to be a very expensive wake-up call.

Let's walk through what's changed, what CBSA is actually looking for, and what you should do before an officer sends you a letter.

What CBSA's Updated Verification Priorities Actually Say

CBSA publishes Trade Compliance Verification priority lists to signal where it plans to focus audit resources. These aren't random. They reflect where the agency believes non-compliance is concentrated, either because of complexity in the rules, because importers are making systematic errors, or because the revenue risk is high enough to justify the effort.

The updated priorities expand scrutiny in two directions:

  • Steel and aluminum imports, particularly goods subject to surtaxes under Canada's retaliatory tariff measures
  • Goods claiming preferential tariff treatment under trade agreements, with CUSMA/USMCA getting particular attention

McMillan's reporting notes that this expansion is deliberate. CBSA is connecting the dots between the retaliatory tariff environment and origin claims. The concern is that some importers are claiming CUSMA preferential rates on goods that don't actually qualify, either because the origin documentation is weak, the rules of origin analysis was never done properly, or the goods have been transshipped in a way that breaks the chain.

If you're claiming tariff treatment code "10" on your CAD for U.S.-origin steel, CBSA wants to know you can back that up.

The Surtax Layer: Why This Verification Cycle Is Different

Canada's retaliatory surtaxes on U.S. goods have added a layer of complexity that didn't exist in previous verification cycles. CBSA Customs Notice 26-23, the United States Surtax Order (2026), and Customs Notice 26-26, which covers guidance on accounting, correction, and adjustment of surtax, have both introduced new obligations around how surtax is calculated, reported, and corrected on import entries.

Here's where it gets complicated. Some goods are subject to surtax. Some are exempt. Some qualify for relief. And the determination of which bucket your goods fall into depends on origin, tariff classification, and in some cases the specific end-use of the product. Get any one of those wrong and you're either overpaying duty or, more dangerously, underpaying it.

CBSA knows that importers are making errors in both directions right now. The verification priority update is partly a response to that. They've seen enough CADs with inconsistent surtax treatment that they've decided to look harder.

Customs Notice 26-26 is worth reading carefully if you haven't already. It sets out how corrections and adjustments to surtax entries are supposed to be handled, including the timelines for voluntary corrections versus corrections made after a verification is triggered. The difference matters because a voluntary correction under the CARM compliance framework looks very different on your compliance profile than a correction made after CBSA has already opened a file on you.

Steel and Aluminum: The Specific Categories Under the Microscope

Not every steel and aluminum import is equally at risk. CBSA's verification resources aren't unlimited, so they prioritize based on revenue exposure and error rates. Based on the updated priorities and the retaliatory tariff context, the categories getting the most attention are:

Flat-Rolled Steel Products

Hot-rolled and cold-rolled flat steel, coated and uncoated, under HS headings 7208 through 7212. These are high-volume, high-value imports and the origin rules under CUSMA are specific. The tariff shift requirements matter here. If your steel was melted and poured in a third country and then processed in the U.S., it may not qualify for CUSMA preference even if the final processing happened in the U.S.

Check your HS heading 7208 entries if you're importing hot-rolled flat steel. Verify that your supplier's certificate of origin actually reflects a proper rules-of-origin analysis, not just a checkbox on a form.

Aluminum Mill Products

Unwrought aluminum, aluminum bars, rods, profiles, and sheet under headings 7601 through 7607. Canada's surtax measures on U.S. aluminum have been particularly contentious, and CBSA has seen a pattern of importers claiming CUSMA preference on aluminum products where the underlying origin is actually Chinese or another non-CUSMA country, with the U.S. acting as a pass-through.

Transshipment is the word CBSA officers use when they're being polite. Tariff evasion is the word they use in penalty notices.

Steel Pipes and Tubes

Headings 7304 through 7306. This category has historically been a verification target, and it's back on the list. The combination of anti-dumping duties, countervailing duties, and now retaliatory surtaxes means the total duty exposure on a misclassified or mis-originated pipe shipment can be substantial. We've seen cases where the total duty differential between the claimed treatment and the correct treatment exceeded $80,000 on a single entry.

Downstream Steel-Containing Products

This is the one that catches importers off guard. CBSA isn't just looking at raw steel. They're looking at finished goods that contain significant steel content, things like structural components, automotive parts, and industrial equipment, where the importer is claiming CUSMA preference but the steel content in the product doesn't meet the applicable rules of origin. The CUSMA rules for steel-intensive products include specific requirements around where the steel was melted and poured, not just where the final product was assembled.

Trade Agreement Origin Claims: What CBSA Is Actually Auditing

CUSMA is the main focus, but CBSA's updated priorities also cover goods claiming preference under CETA, CPTPP, and other agreements. The common thread is that CBSA believes origin claims are being made without adequate supporting documentation, and in some cases without any real analysis at all.

Here's what a CBSA trade compliance verification of your origin claims actually looks like in practice.

The Documentation Request

You'll receive a letter asking you to produce, for a sample of your entries, the documentation supporting your tariff preference claims. That typically means:

  • Certificates of origin or origin declarations from your suppliers
  • Bills of material or product specifications showing the components used in manufacturing
  • Evidence that the goods were shipped directly from the preference country without transshipment through a third country
  • In some cases, producer certifications going back through the supply chain

If you can't produce this documentation within the timeframe CBSA gives you, which is usually 30 days, the preference claim gets denied. You owe the full MFN duty rate plus interest. On a year's worth of entries, that adds up fast.

The Rules of Origin Analysis

A certificate of origin from your U.S. supplier is not the same thing as proof of origin. It's a declaration. CBSA can look behind that declaration. If your supplier signed a CUSMA certificate without actually doing the rules of origin analysis, and CBSA figures that out during a verification, the liability lands on you as the importer of record. Your supplier's error becomes your penalty.

This is one of the most common misconceptions I see. Importers think that having a signed certificate of origin means they're covered. It doesn't. It means you have a piece of paper. CBSA can still disallow the claim if the underlying analysis doesn't support it.

For CUSMA, the rules of origin are set out in the agreement itself and implemented through the CBSA D11 series memoranda. The analysis for most manufactured goods involves either a tariff classification change test, a regional value content test, or both. If you haven't actually worked through that analysis for your key products, you're flying on assumption.

Direct Shipment

Even if your goods genuinely originate in a CUSMA country, you can lose the preference if they weren't shipped directly. Goods that passed through a third country and were stored, repackaged, or further processed there may not qualify. You need through bills of lading or other evidence of direct shipment for every preference claim.

How CARM Changes the Stakes on a Verification

Before CARM, a trade compliance verification was painful but somewhat contained. CBSA would assess additional duties, you'd pay them, maybe you'd get a penalty, and you'd move on.

Under CARM, your compliance history is a living record. Every verification result, every penalty, every voluntary correction feeds into your compliance profile. That profile affects your risk score, which affects how often you get examined, which affects your costs and your release times. A bad verification outcome in 2026 can follow your import program for years.

There's also the financial security angle. If you're a self-assessed importer under CARM and a verification reveals a pattern of non-compliance, CBSA has the authority to require additional security. For a mid-size importer running $5 million a year in duties, that could mean posting a significantly larger bond than you currently carry. Review your CARM readiness position now, not after a verification notice arrives.

Voluntary corrections made proactively, before a verification is triggered, are treated more favourably under CBSA's administrative policy. The penalty matrix under AMPS is graduated based on whether the error was self-identified or found by CBSA. That gap can be the difference between a warning and a $25,000 penalty.

Running Your Own Self-Audit Before CBSA Runs One for You

Honestly, most importers don't do this. They wait until there's a problem. Don't be that importer.

Here's a practical self-audit approach for the current verification environment.

Step 1: Pull Your Steel and Aluminum Entries for the Last Two Years

Filter your CAD history for entries under HS chapters 72, 73, and 76. For each entry, note the tariff treatment code claimed. If you're claiming CUSMA preference, flag those entries for review. If you're claiming surtax exemption or relief, flag those too.

Step 2: Verify Your Origin Documentation Is on File

For every CUSMA claim, you need a valid certificate of origin or origin certification in your records. Under CUSMA, the certification doesn't have to be on a specific form, but it does need to contain all the required data elements. Check that your supplier certifications are current. CUSMA certifications can cover multiple shipments, but they have a four-year validity period and they need to be product-specific enough to actually support the claim.

If you can't find the supporting documentation for an entry, that's a problem you want to fix voluntarily before CBSA asks for it.

Step 3: Check Your Surtax Treatment Against Customs Notice 26-23

CBSA Customs Notice 26-23 sets out which U.S. goods are subject to the 2026 surtax and which are exempt. Go through your steel and aluminum entries and verify that the surtax treatment you applied at the time of entry matches what the notice actually says. Errors here tend to be systematic, meaning if you got it wrong once, you probably got it wrong every time you imported that product.

If you find errors, read Customs Notice 26-26 on corrections and adjustments. It tells you exactly how to file a correction and what the timelines are. Do it before CBSA finds it first.

Step 4: Review Your Rules of Origin Analysis for Top Products

Pick your top ten imported products by duty value where you're claiming preferential treatment. For each one, ask: do we have an actual rules of origin analysis on file, or are we just relying on a supplier certificate? If it's the latter, get the analysis done. Your customs broker or a trade lawyer can help with this. The cost of a proper origin analysis is a fraction of the cost of a failed verification.

Step 5: Check Your Direct Shipment Documentation

For goods coming from the U.S. or other preference countries, confirm you have through bills of lading or equivalent evidence showing the goods came directly without meaningful processing in a third country. This is especially important for goods that move through distribution centers or consolidation hubs.

What Happens If CBSA Sends You a Verification Notice

First, don't panic. A verification notice is not an accusation. It's a request for information. How you respond matters enormously.

Get your customs broker and, depending on the complexity, a trade lawyer involved immediately. The response package you submit needs to be complete, accurate, and organized. Submitting incomplete documentation or documentation that contradicts your entry claims is worse than submitting nothing, because it suggests the problem is bigger than it might actually be.

If you know there are errors in the entries being reviewed, disclose them proactively in your response. CBSA's administrative policy gives credit for voluntary disclosure and cooperation. Trying to defend entries you know are wrong is a losing strategy and it damages your credibility for everything else in the file.

The verification process typically takes three to six months from notice to final determination. During that time, CBSA may ask follow-up questions or request additional documentation. Respond promptly and completely to every request. Delays in your response don't pause the clock on CBSA's timeline, they just make you look uncooperative.

If the verification results in a duty assessment you disagree with, you have the right to request a redetermination under section 60 of the Customs Act. You have 90 days from the date of the assessment to file. Don't miss that deadline.

A Note on Advance Rulings

If you're uncertain about the tariff classification or origin treatment of a product you're importing regularly, an advance ruling is one of the most underused tools available to importers. CBSA will tell you in writing how they'll treat your goods before you import them. That ruling is binding on CBSA as long as the facts don't change.

An advance ruling on origin or tariff classification won't protect you from a verification of past entries, but it will protect your future entries and it demonstrates to CBSA that you're taking compliance seriously. In the current enforcement environment, that matters. Learn more about the advance ruling process and whether it makes sense for your key products.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if my goods are on CBSA's current verification priority list?

CBSA publishes its trade compliance verification priorities on its website, though the list isn't always updated in real time. The current focus on steel, aluminum, and trade agreement origin claims is well documented in the November 2026 reporting from McMillan LLP. If you're importing goods under HS chapters 72, 73, or 76, or claiming CUSMA, CETA, or CPTPP preference on any goods, you should assume you're in a higher-risk category right now and act accordingly.

My supplier gave me a signed CUSMA certificate of origin. Isn't that enough?

It's a start, but it's not a guarantee. CBSA can look behind a certificate of origin and disallow the preference claim if the underlying goods don't actually meet the rules of origin. If your supplier signed a certificate without doing the proper analysis, and CBSA figures that out, you're the one who owes the duties. Get your supplier to confirm they've actually done the rules of origin analysis and ask for supporting documentation if the amounts are significant.

What's the penalty for a failed origin verification?

At minimum, you owe the difference between the preferential duty rate you claimed and the MFN rate that should have applied, plus interest. On top of that, CBSA can assess AMPS penalties under the administrative monetary penalty system. For a systematic error affecting multiple entries, penalties can reach $25,000 per contravention in serious cases. The total exposure on a year's worth of misclassified steel entries can easily reach six figures.

Can I correct past entries voluntarily before a verification is triggered?

Yes, and you should if you find errors. A voluntary correction filed under section 32.2 of the Customs Act before CBSA opens a verification file is treated more favourably under AMPS. You'll still owe the duties and interest, but the penalty exposure is significantly lower than if CBSA finds the error first. Customs Notice 26-26 sets out the specific procedures for correcting surtax entries.

Does CARM affect how verifications work?

CARM doesn't change the legal framework for verifications, but it changes the consequences. Your compliance history under CARM is cumulative and affects your risk profile going forward. A verification that reveals systemic non-compliance can result in increased examination rates, additional security requirements, and closer scrutiny on future entries. Think of it as a compliance credit score. A bad verification is a mark that stays on your file.

We import finished goods from the U.S. that contain Chinese steel. Do we have a problem?

Potentially, yes. CUSMA has specific rules about steel-intensive products that require the steel content to be melted and poured in a CUSMA country. If your U.S. supplier is using Chinese steel in the manufacturing process, the finished goods may not qualify for CUSMA preference even if all the manufacturing happened in the U.S. This is exactly the kind of scenario CBSA is targeting in the current verification cycle. Get a proper rules of origin analysis done on those products before you claim preference on the next shipment.

Sẵn sàng tự động hóa?

Đơn giản hóa công việc hải quan với tín dụng miễn phí

Tiết kiệm thời gian khi phân loại, xác định trị giá hải quan và nghiên cứu tuân thủ, với các công cụ được thiết kế để đơn giản hóa quy trình làm việc của bạn và hỗ trợ mọi quyết định.